I search the online French-English dictionary for the word “bullying.” Harcélement, it tells me. A wikipedia article calls it “le bullying” and states that France is “extremely behind” in dealing with this issue, with a policy of “closing their eyes.” This is not reassuring.
I’m preparing for a meeting with the CPE of the kids’ school. I think he’s the equivalent of a vice-principal. (Meredith, would you agree?) He’s a really nice man, with friendly brown eyes, often chewing gum. I got to know him when I did the English Club at the school last fall. He told me how much he admires my children, and how good their French is “for anglo-saxons,” which amuses me no end. (Talk about damning with faint praise! He means it as a compliment though)
This meeting will not be so chatty, I worry. It’s because Abel is getting picked on at school. Apparently it’s been going on all year but we’re just finding out the extent of it. We knew there were some issues, but it came to a head this week when Elliot got involved. Kids were teasing Abel, picking on him, snatching his recorder and playing keep-away with it while he tried in vain to get it back. Elliot saw what was happening and sauntered over with some of his friends, snatched the flute back, and basically pulled rank…older/bigger/alpha male! Yeah. But Elliot can’t be Abel’s watch dog. The teachers, when appealed to after kids steal Abel’s fountain pen, ruler, pencil sharpener, have proven to be completely useless. Feet of clay all. So, on Elliot’s advice, I appeal to Caesar, as it were.
On Wednesday morning, I trudge off to the meeting. It goes well. The CPE is as nice as ever. He is disturbed. I tell him, “I realize some of it is Moroccan culture (the pushing, hitting, calling names—all of this happens in the teen class I teach, regardless of my best efforts to stop it). But it’s still not good for Abel. I worry that if it’s not stopped, it will escalate, and regardless, it will affect his self esteem.”
The CPE agrees. He asks for names, promises to help. That wikipedia article was wrong—this seems exactly what anyone anywhere would do. He promises to talk to Abel’s homeroom teacher and the kids involved; he says that if there are any further incidents we must come straight to him, no appointment necessary.
I know that he follows through, because two days later a kid in Elliot’s class tells him that he overheard kids in Abel’s class threatening to beat him up because he told on them to the CPE. Elliot dispatches himself to keep an eye on his sibling as much as possible, and so far, nothing has happened.
Sure, some of this is our nationality. We’re the only Americans at the school—or anglo-saxons, as I prefer to think of us. As things are tense on a global stage, maybe not specifically now but overall, we can expect some hassle. Abel has gotten picked on specifically for being an American before. During the first year of the Iraq war we were living in France, and an Arab boy, about 5 years older than Abel, took it upon himself to take out on Abel the feelings watching the evening news stirred in him. But we were able to work that out through talking to the kid.
But honestly, that’s not what’s going on here. Elliot and Ilsa have no problems. Abel is young for his age, small for his age. He’s a sweet kid—thoughtful, caring—but when teased, he responds. He gets upset. He struggles a bit with his French and that doesn’t help. In no way do I want to blame the victim, but sometimes he misses out on social norms, such as the time he was practicing the recorder at recess.
What bugs me so much is how many clues I missed along the way. It’s been going on all year, every day. Now I can see clearly how it’s been affecting him, but at the time I just worried that he didn’t seem to have settled in. How could I not have realized?
21 comments
April 12, 2010 at 12:11 pm
meredith
Yes, the CPE is like a vice-principal, second in charge kind of position. I hope he can help Abel. But kids this age are horrible, at least from what I’ve seen in the French system. My girls’ school has a couple of “souffre douleurs” and they really get picked on bad sometimes. One of them is one of my American friend’s daughters, She gets picked on not because she’s half American, but because she too doesn’t always fit the Jr High’s social norm mold (and thank goodness, because she’s such a sweet, smart, pretty girl). I don’t remember Jr High being so tough way back when in the states, but times have changed everywhere and kids seem to have such a different set of values and references than we did.
April 12, 2010 at 12:42 pm
Maria
Honestly, I remember middle school being completely awful in this regard in the states when I was that age (early 80s). I think it’s a function of the age of the kids, and maybe less supervision than kids that age need. They *seem* to be fairly self-sufficient, no longer need help putting on shoes or opening their thermoses at lunch, but socially and emotionally I believe kids that age need more parenting/supervision than infants. My experience was terrible. Good for you for helping Abel out!
April 12, 2010 at 1:29 pm
Miss Footloose
I understand that school bullying is one of those behaviors difficult to change from the “top down” because it cannot be patrolled every minute of the day. And kids will find a way.
On TV recently someone said change needs to come from the kids themselves. Somehow it has to be not “cool’ to bully. So it takes a PR campaign, student-group, and peer-group effort, to change the culture.
This makes sense to me, but it will not be easy. It will take a group of kids in the school willing to take on that challenge. Maybe an adult will be able to help them get started. There are lots of “good” kids, so there may be some who might be interested in making it their cause.
April 12, 2010 at 1:32 pm
Miss Footloose
And let me add, I know how hard it is. We have a son we adopted at age 6 from abroad, and he never quite fit it, did not catch on to social cues, and had a hard time.
Hang in there!
April 12, 2010 at 1:56 pm
Jennifer
I hope that the friends he does have & all the things he’s good at — the things that give him self-confidence — can help him pull through. As a kid I remember arguing w/ my parents about how much more important friends were than family, but looking back that was totally not true. The love & respect from my parents gave me a solid foundation I rely on even now.
My son misses social cues, too. Middle school is going to be a terror.
April 12, 2010 at 3:02 pm
LIB
I second (third, fourth, etc.) the comments above.
You did the right thing in talking to the CPE; and kudos to him for following thru (even tho he does damn you with faint praise.)
The only thing I would add is to encourage Able in the area of his strengths. As an example, Ali’s involvement in Band really helped her thru tumultuous times.
April 12, 2010 at 4:00 pm
Kris
Poor Abel! I’m glad you all are addressing this head on and am so proud of Elliot for taking up for him!
Give them both a giant hug for me.
April 12, 2010 at 4:25 pm
Jeanne A
Same thing happening to my daughter here——I think I’m going to homeschool her soon———
April 12, 2010 at 5:22 pm
thisprovencallife
My eldest daughter suffers also. Not so much from bullying but from being different, in her own world most of the time. Her best friend moved away suddenly during the February vacation when we were in the states and we don’t have a new phone number. Olivia returns home each day from school upset that no one likes her or wants to play with her at recess.
She’s going to be my special child, the one who doesn’t follow the norm. I worry about her school years and her self esteem but I actually feel that if she is encouraged in her abilities, then her future will be more vivid. I don’t have any advice on bullying but I agree with LIb, Abel should get all the encouragement and praise for his talents and interests and he will find his place. And Bravo to his big brother for sticking up for him.
April 12, 2010 at 6:44 pm
Robin from Israel
My heart goes out to Abel, junior high can be a very cruel place.
In my own case school was often miserable but a non-school youth group really let me come into my own and find my own light. Is there some group/activity/club he might be able to join to give him his own safe space to shine?
April 12, 2010 at 8:37 pm
meredith
Back again,…don’t be too hard on yourself, it’s not always easy to read our kids, they’re pretty good at hiding their problems. He knows you are backing him up, that’s important. Time usually helps take care of these things, too.
April 12, 2010 at 10:02 pm
jean
Not only shouldn’t you blame the victim, you shouldn’t blame yourself. You’ve done the right thing by talking to the VP and making him aware of the situation. Middle school kids are bastards. (Sorry. I’m sure it sounds nicer in French.) Now you just need to make sure that your son keeps you in the loop and you follow up if needed.
April 13, 2010 at 12:20 am
KathiD
Now, please, do NOT take on that mother guilt! You have noticed, and you are doing something about it. I can’t imagine the hurt of having your child picked on and feeling rather helpless about it. After all, you can’t very well go to school with him every day. It’s great that his brother is there to step in sometimes, but he can’t always be there, either. I think your instincts are right, that some kids are just a little easier to bully than others. Such a sad situation.
When I was a teenager, my young nephew WAS the bully. When he was 3, his baby brother died, and after crumbling apart for a couple of years, his parents split up. He was a sweet boy, a good boy, but he took out his pain on the kids at school that he could push around. Having your kid BE the bully is also tough. Fortunately, my nephew found other ways to channel his anger and hurt, mostly in sports, and his bullying career didn’t last long. Well, and his father let him know that bullying wasn’t going to be tolerated, no matter what. It’s just a miserable situation, and I hope yours has a good resolution.
Also, everybody is right about junior high, of course. That’s the worst age of all. Those blossoming hormones, yeeks!
April 13, 2010 at 12:23 am
KathiD
P.S. Of course, if Abel could master the art of acting like he doesn’t care, it would probably help. But that’s like telling someone, “Now stop being the way you are and be like someone else!” I know, because I have always been the “different” one too, and no matter what anyone tells me, I still can’t snap to and be “the way I’m supposed to be.”
April 13, 2010 at 7:12 am
Linda
My daughter was always the outsider and it was so hard to watch and hear about. She had some girlfriends though and I think that helped. I missed some really major clues in other areas of her life which made me feel guilty. I don’t know what I could have done differently thinking about it now. Being a parent is the hardest job in the world.
April 13, 2010 at 4:12 pm
LG
Planet nomad, wow, this is so sad. I remember Nathan saying repeatedly how much he liked his boarding school because there was no bullying. Made me think about what kind of bullying he had experienced in Canada at middle school that I NEVER KNEW ABOUT. Being a mom is hard, being a kid in middle school is harder. Courage! My heart breaks for you both.
April 13, 2010 at 5:26 pm
sue b
I went through this with my daughter when she was in middle school. We also encouraged our daughter to ignore it, etc. I wish I could tell you that it all worked out, but talking to teachers, the principal, etc. didn’t change things. I’m not sure the standard advice works, since once someone is chosen as a target, it tends to persist. As others have said, the culture of the school has to change so that it’s not “cool” to bully. Because that’s the reason kids do it, to gain status or to be part of the group, or to avoid being bullied themselves. It’s not driven by the behavior of the victim. Some kids become targets for the most trivial of reasons, or simply because they seem vulnerable. Things changed for my daughter only after she changed schools. If it continues, then perhaps consider taking him out of that school.
April 14, 2010 at 8:52 am
MaryWitzl
The exact same thing happened to my youngest daughter here (wastebasket dumped over her head, taunted by older, tougher kids, ignored, scorned, ridiculed, etc.) and we too were slow to react. I know how you feel! And no, it’s not just cultural. Kids can get bullied for all sorts of reasons, in all sorts of ways.
I can imagine how Abel feels too! I was a skinny, awkward kid with poor social skills and no idea of how to act around my peers. The one good thing about growing up bullied is that if you live through it, you’re tougher and stronger than the popular kids who swan through high school secure in the knowledge that the world loves them and thinks they’re perfect.
April 15, 2010 at 3:10 am
Kelly @ Love Well
I have no advice. But I’m heartsick for you and Abel and the whole situation. I pray it gets better and quickly.
April 16, 2010 at 1:08 am
Susan (WhyMommy)
Tough situation. I like the thought of Elliot striding over to stick up for Abel, though. I hope mine do that for each other whenthey grow up a little too.
April 17, 2010 at 6:02 pm
gretchen from lifenut
Oh, no. My heart goes out to Abel and to you. It’s such an awful, helpless feeling. One of my boys had a dismal time last year at school, but this year things have improved somewhat. He made a good friend, and that boosted his confidence tremendously. Total answer to prayer. Still, I’m always on guard. Mama bear, you know.
You have such a wonderful family. He’s ultimately safe, he’s loved, his big brother has his back. That’s priceless.